Searching for

About
Awards
Fellows
Events
News
Contact
Support
Current
All
About
Awards
Fellows
Events
News
Contact
Support
Current
All

SOM Foundation
224 South Michigan Avenue
Chicago, IL 60604

Terms of Use
Join Our Mailing List

Searching for

About
Awards
Fellows
Events
News
Contact
Support
Current
All

2005 Bachelor of Architecture
Additive Subtraction

Brian Knight traveled to Caracas, Fez, and Portland to study how subtractive spaces—vacant lots, self-regulating zones, residual spaces, the informal, and nonplanned—act as counterpoints to the way order and consumption control the city.

Brian Knight
Southern California Institute of Architecture

View Portfolio
View Final Report

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 01

Caracas from El Avila. © Brian Knight.

Jury
Mustafa Abadan (Cochair)
Sulan Kolatan
Gregg Pasquarelli
Marilyn Taylor (Cochair)
Tod Williams

Urban planning has always been about colonization, the marking of boundaries, of order and form. Architecture is the instrument of this organization. It transforms the cluttered into the cultivated, the fallow into the productive, and the void into the built. It is the power of accumulation, of accretion, of addition. But very little consideration is given to the act of subtraction in urban design and planning. As such, I am interested in a type of urban space that falls outside the scope of what we call normal or significant. These subtractive spaces—vacant lots, self-regulating zones, residual spaces, the informal, and nonplanned—act as counterpoints to the way order and consumption control the city. Many of these spaces contain the ineffable qualities that architecture tries so hard to accomplish yet so very often fails to actualize.

The first view of these spaces is that they are unacceptable due to the socioeconomic deterioration and abandonment implied in them. They disrupt the image of order. A second view holds that these spaces offer room for spontaneous, creative appropriation and informal uses. These are the kind of uses that would normally have a hard time finding room within the urban fabric and its demands of commerce and commodity. Although they are not the revenue-generating sites that most cities need, they supply their residents with services that the city is not able to supply. Like a comma in a sentence, these spaces are a pause in the built environment that allows one to step back and more clearly read the character of the city as a whole. What can we as emerging architects and planners leverage from these built and unbuilt environments that currently lie outside our discipline yet resonate and serve those who come into contact with them every day?

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 02

La Cruz del Este neighborhood, Caracas. © Brian Knight.

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 03

La Cruz del Este neighborhood, Caracas. © Brian Knight.

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 04

La Cruz del Este neighborhood, Caracas. © Brian Knight.

A Vitruvian relic: the clepsydra (water clock) of the Bou Inania Medersa, Fez. © Brian Knight.

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 05

The opposite view from a doorway. This one is looking out on the Tala’a Kebira, Fez. © Brian Knight.

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 06
Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 07

Years of industrial detritus are somewhat gracefully being subsumed by the vegetation that surrounds the site, Portland. © Brian Knight.

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 08

Years of industrial detritus are somewhat gracefully being subsumed by the vegetation that surrounds the site, Portland. © Brian Knight.

The site is now used primarily for the traveling Cirque de Soleil that visits every summer. Close proximity to the river and several rail lines could make this an important public space for the city of Portland. © Brian Knight.

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight final report 09

Itinerary

When the generic is seen as unique and when the obvious is seen as enlightening, there comes a forgetfulness that threatens to severely limit the way we are able to experience our day-to-day lives. Our current bureaucratic, top-down urban planning and zoning policies have for the most part, created public spaces that are monotonous and trivial when one considers the critical roles these spaces should play. Therefore, my itinerary will include visits to urban areas outside of the normative consciousness of architectural education and practice. Subtractive spaces—economically marginalized, materially relegated—yet additive in the imaginative way they look at alternative versions of program, urban planning, zoning, and materials and methods. Innovative informal architecture can help to reactivate the terrain vague of our emerging postindustrial city centers. The itinerary is broken into three stages; past solutions and continuing evolutions (Fez); present conditions and innovations (Caracas); and near-future, emerging scenarios (Portland).

Somf 2005 bachelor architecture brian knight headshot

Brian Knight
Southern California Institute of Architecture

Brian Knight

is the president and CEO of BFK ARCHITECTURE + PLANNING. He is a registered architect in the State of California as well as a LEED Accredited Professional and has worked in a variety of market sectors over the course of his career. Knight has been involved in many award-winning built projects from California, Texas, and the western United States to Asia and the Middle East. The focus of his work is now concentrated in the residential, mixed-use, and commercial markets. Included in his portfolio are residential projects ranging from 24 to 720 units and commercial projects from 2,500 sq. ft. to over 100,000 sq. ft. He began his career as a graphic designer and art director, working for over fifteen years in the publishing, marketing, advertising, branding, and environmental graphics fields. Knight received his Bachelor of Architecture degree from the Southern California Institute of Architecture.

©2025 SOM Foundation

Terms of Use

Join Our Mailing List